• Money
    • Budget
    • Shop
    • Travel
    • Stories
  • Career
    • Advice
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Freelance
    • Small Business
  • Investing
    • General
    • IRA + 401K
    • Stocks + Bonds
    • Retirement Planning
    • Estate
  • The Basics
    • Student Loans
    • Credit Cards
    • Debt
    • Taxes
    • More
  1. Home
  2. The Basics
  3. Home Ownership
  4. How Statistics Might Mess With Your Mortgage Fees

How Statistics Might Mess With Your Mortgage Fees

January 29, 2019
By: Esther Bergdahl
  • Share
  • Share on Facebook
Two cute young Black women in glasses smiling together
credit: @chalejoelthis/Twenty20

Congratulations: You've done it. You've bought a house. The nonsense of navigating the home-buying process is behind you. Now you get to pay a mortgage for 30 years. At last, you think. Something painful, but simple.

Video of the Day

Researchers at Penn State University have some bad news about that. According to a new study, minority mortgage-seekers may face higher fees than white mortgage-seekers with similar qualifications. In a statistical analysis of a dataset containing more than 25,000 mortgage brokers, the team at Penn State found that minority borrowers pay about 8 percent more with white mortgage agents than white borrowers. That's a difference of around $400.

The obvious question is whether racism is directly responsible for this kind of gap. Real estate has always been used to enforce white supremacy, with mortgages in particular wielded as a tool of division and oppression. The Penn researchers did not find, however, that white mortgage brokers are especially racist. Instead, they suggest that the bias is much subtler and more systemic.

Statistical discrimination stems from a lack of data. It's an economic theory that when people don't have enough information about an individual or a group, they fall back on "easily observable characteristics," as the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics puts it. That's how years of education becomes a stand-in for conscientiousness, and other shorthands. Brokers overall have less data on minority borrowers; the data they have may also be less nuanced, due to its small size. This is still unfair profiling, but give it a name and it may be easier to call out — and hopefully correct.



Show Comments

Related Articles

Is the Wage Gap a Myth?

Is the Wage Gap a Myth?

Career
Advice
By: Fiona Tapp
When Airbnb Helps and Hurts a Neighborhood

When Airbnb Helps and Hurts a Neighborhood

Money
Travel
By: Esther Bergdahl

PARTNER CONTENT

Money Mistakes Wealthy People Don't Make

Money Mistakes Wealthy People Don't Make

Salary of a Ship Broker

Salary of a Ship Broker

Money
Budget
By: Mary Strain
How to Find Foreclosed Homes

How to Find Foreclosed Homes

The Basics
Home Ownership
By: Maya Black
How to Create a "House for Sale by Owner" Flier

How to Create a "House for Sale by Owner" Flier

The Basics
Home Ownership
By: KC Hernandez

Get Weekly Savings& Finance Tips.

  • Money
  • Career
  • Investing
  • The Basics
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright Policy
© 2019 Leaf Group Ltd. Leaf Group Media

Get Weekly Savings
& Finance Tips.

Money Made Easier.

Please enter a valid email.